1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (비룡천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .4200 .2100 .2999 .0630 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .8100 .6150 .3000 .1845 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 1.0100 .9100 .1000 .0910 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 1.3100 1.1600 .1000 .1160 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1615 10.0000 1.9200 1.6150 .1000 .1615 .1615 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1067 5.0000 2.3500 2.1350 .0500 .1067 .1067 .1067 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0419 3.3300 2.6700 2.5100 .0167 .0419 .0419 .0419 .0419 .0000 .0000 .0368 2.0000 2.8600 2.7650 .0133 .0368 .0368 .0368 .0368 .0368 .0000 .0219 1.2500 2.9800 2.9200 .0075 .0219 .0219 .0219 .0219 .0219 .0219 .0075 1.0000 3.0500 3.0150 .0025 .0075 .0075 .0075 .0075 .0075 .0075 .0103 .6700 3.1800 3.1150 .0033 .0103 .0103 .0103 .0103 .0103 .0103 .0054 .5000 3.2100 3.1950 .0017 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 SUM .8466 .3921 .2306 .1238 .0819 .0451 1.2554 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .4545 .6160 .7227 .7646 .8014 -.4089 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .4545 .6160 .7227 .7646 .8014 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 2.5173 3.4119 4.0032 4.2354 4.4390 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (신상천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .4500 .2250 .2999 .0675 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .6500 .5500 .3000 .1650 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .7500 .7000 .1000 .0700 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .9300 .8400 .1000 .0840 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1100 10.0000 1.2700 1.1000 .1000 .1100 .1100 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0790 5.0000 1.8900 1.5800 .0500 .0790 .0790 .0790 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0347 3.3300 2.2600 2.0750 .0167 .0347 .0347 .0347 .0347 .0000 .0000 .0325 2.0000 2.6200 2.4400 .0133 .0325 .0325 .0325 .0325 .0325 .0000 .0205 1.2500 2.8500 2.7350 .0075 .0205 .0205 .0205 .0205 .0205 .0205 .0073 1.0000 2.9500 2.9000 .0025 .0073 .0073 .0073 .0073 .0073 .0073 .0101 .6700 3.1500 3.0500 .0033 .0101 .0101 .0101 .0101 .0101 .0101 .0054 .5000 3.2000 3.1750 .0017 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 .0054 SUM .6858 .2993 .1893 .1103 .0757 .0432 1.2554 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .3865 .4965 .5755 .6101 .6426 -.5696 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .3865 .4965 .5755 .6101 .6426 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 2.1407 2.7500 3.1876 3.3795 3.5592 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (사성천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .3200 .1600 .2999 .0480 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .3800 .3500 .3000 .1050 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .4200 .4000 .1000 .0400 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .4800 .4500 .1000 .0450 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0540 10.0000 .6000 .5400 .1000 .0540 .0540 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0330 5.0000 .7200 .6600 .0500 .0330 .0330 .0330 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0129 3.3300 .8200 .7700 .0167 .0129 .0129 .0129 .0129 .0000 .0000 .0118 2.0000 .9600 .8900 .0133 .0118 .0118 .0118 .0118 .0118 .0000 .0076 1.2500 1.0600 1.0100 .0075 .0076 .0076 .0076 .0076 .0076 .0076 .0028 1.0000 1.1600 1.1100 .0025 .0028 .0028 .0028 .0028 .0028 .0028 .0039 .6700 1.2200 1.1900 .0033 .0039 .0039 .0039 .0039 .0039 .0039 .0021 .5000 1.2400 1.2300 .0017 .0021 .0021 .0021 .0021 .0021 .0021 .0021 SUM .3660 .1281 .0741 .0411 .0282 .0164 1.2521 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2380 .2920 .3250 .3378 .3497 -.8860 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2380 .2920 .3250 .3378 .3497 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 1.3182 1.6173 1.8001 1.8713 1.9369 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (낭월천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .4500 .2250 .2999 .0675 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .6000 .5250 .3000 .1575 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .6400 .6200 .1000 .0620 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .7200 .6800 .1000 .0680 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0790 10.0000 .8600 .7900 .1000 .0790 .0790 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0480 5.0000 1.0600 .9600 .0500 .0480 .0480 .0480 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0192 3.3300 1.2400 1.1500 .0167 .0192 .0192 .0192 .0192 .0000 .0000 .0169 2.0000 1.3000 1.2700 .0133 .0169 .0169 .0169 .0169 .0169 .0000 .0099 1.2500 1.3500 1.3250 .0075 .0099 .0099 .0099 .0099 .0099 .0099 .0034 1.0000 1.3900 1.3700 .0025 .0034 .0034 .0034 .0034 .0034 .0034 .0046 .6700 1.4000 1.3950 .0033 .0046 .0046 .0046 .0046 .0046 .0046 .0024 .5000 1.4200 1.4100 .0017 .0024 .0024 .0024 .0024 .0024 .0024 .0024 SUM .5384 .1835 .1045 .0565 .0373 .0204 1.2524 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .3550 .4340 .4820 .5012 .5181 -.7140 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .3550 .4340 .4820 .5012 .5181 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 1.9662 2.4038 2.6697 2.7760 2.8696 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (곤령천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .1800 .0900 .2999 .0270 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .2500 .2150 .3000 .0645 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .3500 .3000 .1000 .0300 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .4000 .3750 .1000 .0375 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0575 10.0000 .7500 .5750 .1000 .0575 .0575 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0488 5.0000 1.2000 .9750 .0500 .0488 .0488 .0488 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0238 3.3300 1.6500 1.4250 .0167 .0238 .0238 .0238 .0238 .0000 .0000 .0233 2.0000 1.8500 1.7500 .0133 .0233 .0233 .0233 .0233 .0233 .0000 .0157 1.2500 2.3500 2.1000 .0075 .0157 .0157 .0157 .0157 .0157 .0157 .0059 1.0000 2.4000 2.3750 .0025 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0085 .6700 2.7500 2.5750 .0033 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0048 .5000 2.8500 2.8000 .0017 .0048 .0048 .0048 .0048 .0048 .0048 .0048 SUM .3473 .1883 .1308 .0820 .0582 .0349 1.2548 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .1590 .2165 .2652 .2890 .3123 -.9075 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .1590 .2165 .2652 .2890 .3123 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) .8806 1.1991 1.4692 1.6010 1.7299 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (숫골천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 1.2500 .6250 .2999 .1874 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 1.6800 1.4650 .3000 .4395 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 1.8900 1.7850 .1000 .1785 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 2.1000 1.9950 .1000 .1995 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .2290 10.0000 2.4800 2.2900 .1000 .2290 .2290 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1320 5.0000 2.8000 2.6400 .0500 .1320 .1320 .1320 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0492 3.3300 3.0900 2.9450 .0167 .0492 .0492 .0492 .0492 .0000 .0000 .0415 2.0000 3.1500 3.1200 .0133 .0415 .0415 .0415 .0415 .0415 .0000 .0241 1.2500 3.2800 3.2150 .0075 .0241 .0241 .0241 .0241 .0241 .0241 .0083 1.0000 3.3500 3.3150 .0025 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0111 .6700 3.4000 3.3750 .0033 .0111 .0111 .0111 .0111 .0111 .0111 .0058 .5000 3.4800 3.4400 .0017 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0058 SUM 1.5060 .5011 .2721 .1401 .0909 .0494 1.2558 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) 1.0049 1.2339 1.3659 1.4151 1.4566 .2502 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) 1.0049 1.2339 1.3659 1.4151 1.4566 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 5.5663 6.8347 7.5659 7.8383 8.0681 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (송문천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 3.2000 1.6000 .2999 .4798 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 4.5500 3.8750 .3000 1.1625 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 5.3000 4.9250 .1000 .4925 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 6.1500 5.7250 .1000 .5725 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .6835 10.0000 7.5200 6.8350 .1000 .6835 .6835 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .4130 5.0000 9.0000 8.2600 .0500 .4130 .4130 .4130 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1603 3.3300 10.2000 9.6000 .0167 .1603 .1603 .1603 .1603 .0000 .0000 .1378 2.0000 10.5200 10.3600 .0133 .1378 .1378 .1378 .1378 .1378 .0000 .0829 1.2500 11.5800 11.0500 .0075 .0829 .0829 .0829 .0829 .0829 .0829 .0292 1.0000 11.8000 11.6900 .0025 .0292 .0292 .0292 .0292 .0292 .0292 .0399 .6700 12.4000 12.1000 .0033 .0399 .0399 .0399 .0399 .0399 .0399 .0212 .5000 12.5800 12.4900 .0017 .0212 .0212 .0212 .0212 .0212 .0212 .0212 SUM 4.2752 1.5679 .8844 .4714 .3111 .1733 1.2712 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) 2.7073 3.3908 3.8038 3.9642 4.1019 3.0040 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) 2.7073 3.3908 3.8038 3.9642 4.1019 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 14.9959 18.7818 21.0694 21.9574 22.7206 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (안골천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .2500 .1250 .2999 .0375 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .4500 .3500 .3000 .1050 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .6000 .5250 .1000 .0525 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .8200 .7100 .1000 .0710 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1000 10.0000 1.1800 1.0000 .1000 .1000 .1000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0815 5.0000 2.0800 1.6300 .0500 .0815 .0815 .0815 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0444 3.3300 3.2400 2.6600 .0167 .0444 .0444 .0444 .0444 .0000 .0000 .0442 2.0000 3.4100 3.3250 .0133 .0442 .0442 .0442 .0442 .0442 .0000 .0275 1.2500 3.9200 3.6650 .0075 .0275 .0275 .0275 .0275 .0275 .0275 .0100 1.0000 4.0800 4.0000 .0025 .0100 .0100 .0100 .0100 .0100 .0100 .0141 .6700 4.4900 4.2850 .0033 .0141 .0141 .0141 .0141 .0141 .0141 .0077 .5000 4.5800 4.5350 .0017 .0077 .0077 .0077 .0077 .0077 .0077 .0077 SUM .5955 .3295 .2295 .1480 .1036 .0593 1.2577 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2660 .3660 .4475 .4919 .5361 -.6622 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2660 .3660 .4475 .4919 .5361 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 1.4733 2.0272 2.4786 2.7247 2.9696 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (사기점골천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .6300 .3150 .2999 .0945 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .9800 .8050 .3000 .2415 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 1.1500 1.0650 .1000 .1065 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 1.3800 1.2650 .1000 .1265 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1645 10.0000 1.9100 1.6450 .1000 .1645 .1645 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1122 5.0000 2.5800 2.2450 .0500 .1122 .1122 .1122 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0493 3.3300 3.3200 2.9500 .0167 .0493 .0493 .0493 .0493 .0000 .0000 .0450 2.0000 3.4500 3.3850 .0133 .0450 .0450 .0450 .0450 .0450 .0000 .0272 1.2500 3.8000 3.6250 .0075 .0272 .0272 .0272 .0272 .0272 .0272 .0096 1.0000 3.9100 3.8550 .0025 .0096 .0096 .0096 .0096 .0096 .0096 .0132 .6700 4.1200 4.0150 .0033 .0132 .0132 .0132 .0132 .0132 .0132 .0071 .5000 4.2100 4.1650 .0017 .0071 .0071 .0071 .0071 .0071 .0071 .0071 SUM .9972 .4282 .2637 .1514 .1022 .0572 1.2571 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .5690 .7335 .8457 .8950 .9400 -.2599 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .5690 .7335 .8457 .8950 .9400 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 3.1515 4.0627 4.6844 4.9573 5.2067 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (소룡골천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .2400 .1200 .2999 .0360 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .4500 .3450 .3000 .1035 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .5800 .5150 .1000 .0515 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .7600 .6700 .1000 .0670 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1000 10.0000 1.2400 1.0000 .1000 .1000 .1000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0730 5.0000 1.6800 1.4600 .0500 .0730 .0730 .0730 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0328 3.3300 2.2500 1.9650 .0167 .0328 .0328 .0328 .0328 .0000 .0000 .0313 2.0000 2.4500 2.3500 .0133 .0313 .0313 .0313 .0313 .0313 .0000 .0186 1.2500 2.5100 2.4800 .0075 .0186 .0186 .0186 .0186 .0186 .0186 .0064 1.0000 2.5900 2.5500 .0025 .0064 .0064 .0064 .0064 .0064 .0064 .0085 .6700 2.5500 2.5700 .0033 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0085 .0045 .5000 2.7800 2.6650 .0017 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 SUM .5330 .2751 .1751 .1021 .0692 .0380 1.2545 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2580 .3580 .4310 .4638 .4951 -.7215 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2580 .3580 .4310 .4638 .4951 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 1.4290 1.9829 2.3872 2.5690 2.7421 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (머들령천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .2200 .1100 .2999 .0330 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .4200 .3200 .3000 .0960 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .4500 .4350 .1000 .0435 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .5800 .5150 .1000 .0515 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0715 10.0000 .8500 .7150 .1000 .0715 .0715 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0507 5.0000 1.1800 1.0150 .0500 .0507 .0507 .0507 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0214 3.3300 1.3800 1.2800 .0167 .0214 .0214 .0214 .0214 .0000 .0000 .0195 2.0000 1.5500 1.4650 .0133 .0195 .0195 .0195 .0195 .0195 .0000 .0122 1.2500 1.7100 1.6300 .0075 .0122 .0122 .0122 .0122 .0122 .0122 .0044 1.0000 1.7900 1.7500 .0025 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0061 .6700 1.9100 1.8500 .0033 .0061 .0061 .0061 .0061 .0061 .0061 .0033 .5000 1.9500 1.9300 .0017 .0033 .0033 .0033 .0033 .0033 .0033 .0033 SUM .4131 .1891 .1176 .0668 .0455 .0260 1.2533 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2240 .2955 .3462 .3676 .3871 -.8402 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .2240 .2955 .3462 .3676 .3871 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 1.2407 1.6367 1.9178 2.0362 2.1441 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (곡남천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .0500 .0250 .2999 .0075 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .1200 .0850 .3000 .0255 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .1800 .1500 .1000 .0150 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .2400 .2100 .1000 .0210 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0345 10.0000 .4500 .3450 .1000 .0345 .0345 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0313 5.0000 .8000 .6250 .0500 .0313 .0313 .0313 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0188 3.3300 1.4500 1.1250 .0167 .0188 .0188 .0188 .0188 .0000 .0000 .0217 2.0000 1.8100 1.6300 .0133 .0217 .0217 .0217 .0217 .0217 .0000 .0152 1.2500 2.2500 2.0300 .0075 .0152 .0152 .0152 .0152 .0152 .0152 .0058 1.0000 2.3800 2.3150 .0025 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0058 .0081 .6700 2.5100 2.4450 .0033 .0081 .0081 .0081 .0081 .0081 .0081 .0044 .5000 2.6100 2.5600 .0017 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0044 .0044 SUM .2086 .1396 .1051 .0739 .0551 .0334 1.2544 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .0690 .1035 .1347 .1535 .1752 -1.0457 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .0690 .1035 .1347 .1535 .1752 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) .3822 .5733 .7464 .8504 .9705 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (산직천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .4100 .2050 .2999 .0615 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .7700 .5900 .3000 .1770 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .9100 .8400 .1000 .0840 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 1.1300 1.0200 .1000 .1020 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .1295 10.0000 1.4600 1.2950 .1000 .1295 .1295 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0817 5.0000 1.8100 1.6350 .0500 .0817 .0817 .0817 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0326 3.3300 2.1000 1.9550 .0167 .0326 .0326 .0326 .0326 .0000 .0000 .0287 2.0000 2.2100 2.1550 .0133 .0287 .0287 .0287 .0287 .0287 .0000 .0172 1.2500 2.3800 2.2950 .0075 .0172 .0172 .0172 .0172 .0172 .0172 .0060 1.0000 2.4500 2.4150 .0025 .0060 .0060 .0060 .0060 .0060 .0060 .0083 .6700 2.6100 2.5300 .0033 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0083 .0045 .5000 2.6600 2.6350 .0017 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 .0045 SUM .7331 .3086 .1791 .0974 .0647 .0361 1.2545 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .4245 .5540 .6357 .6684 .6970 -.5214 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .4245 .5540 .6357 .6684 .6970 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) 2.3512 3.0685 3.5213 3.7021 3.8609 .0000 1 BENEFIT ANALYSIS (먹티천) FREQ- DAMAGE AVERAGE DISCRETE BEFORE 5YEAR 10YEAR 20YEAR 30YEAR 50YEAR UENCY DAMAGE FREQUENCY CONST. 80YEAR ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 10**6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 99.9900 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 70.0000 .0240 .0120 .2999 .0036 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 40.0000 .0610 .0425 .3000 .0127 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 30.0000 .0910 .0760 .1000 .0076 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 20.0000 .1400 .1155 .1000 .0115 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0192 10.0000 .2450 .1925 .1000 .0192 .0192 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0166 5.0000 .4200 .3325 .0500 .0166 .0166 .0166 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0086 3.3300 .6100 .5150 .0167 .0086 .0086 .0086 .0086 .0000 .0000 .0088 2.0000 .7100 .6600 .0133 .0088 .0088 .0088 .0088 .0088 .0000 .0059 1.2500 .8600 .7850 .0075 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0059 .0022 1.0000 .9100 .8850 .0025 .0022 .0022 .0022 .0022 .0022 .0022 .0032 .6700 1.0100 .9600 .0033 .0032 .0032 .0032 .0032 .0032 .0032 .0017 .5000 1.0410 1.0255 .0017 .0017 .0017 .0017 .0017 .0017 .0017 .0017 SUM .1018 .0663 .0470 .0304 .0218 .0130 1.2517 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .0355 .0547 .0714 .0800 .0888 -1.1500 1 RATE OF INCOME INCREASE = .08 RATE OF INTEREST = .08 THE LIFE OF FACILITIES = 80 N (1)=(1+G)**N (2)=(1+I)**N (3)=(1)/(2) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 1.0760 1.0800 .9963 2 1.1578 1.1664 .9926 3 1.2458 1.2597 .9889 4 1.3404 1.3605 .9853 5 1.4423 1.4693 .9816 6 1.5519 1.5869 .9780 7 1.6699 1.7138 .9744 8 1.7968 1.8509 .9708 9 1.9333 1.9990 .9672 10 2.0803 2.1589 .9636 11 2.2384 2.3316 .9600 12 2.4085 2.5182 .9564 13 2.5915 2.7196 .9529 14 2.7885 2.9372 .9494 15 3.0004 3.1722 .9459 16 3.2285 3.4259 .9424 17 3.4738 3.7000 .9389 18 3.7378 3.9960 .9354 19 4.0219 4.3157 .9319 20 4.3276 4.6610 .9285 21 4.6565 5.0338 .9250 22 5.0104 5.4365 .9216 23 5.3912 5.8715 .9182 24 5.8009 6.3412 .9148 25 6.2418 6.8485 .9114 26 6.7161 7.3964 .9080 27 7.2266 7.9881 .9047 28 7.7758 8.6271 .9013 29 8.3667 9.3173 .8980 30 9.0026 10.0627 .8947 31 9.6868 10.8677 .8913 32 10.4230 11.7371 .8880 33 11.2151 12.6760 .8848 34 12.0675 13.6901 .8815 35 12.9846 14.7853 .8782 36 13.9715 15.9682 .8750 37 15.0333 17.2456 .8717 38 16.1758 18.6253 .8685 39 17.4052 20.1153 .8653 40 18.7280 21.7245 .8621 41 20.1513 23.4625 .8589 42 21.6828 25.3395 .8557 43 23.3307 27.3666 .8525 44 25.1038 29.5560 .8494 45 27.0117 31.9204 .8462 46 29.0646 34.4741 .8431 47 31.2735 37.2320 .8400 48 33.6503 40.2106 .8369 49 36.2077 43.4274 .8338 50 38.9595 46.9016 .8307 51 41.9204 50.6537 .8276 52 45.1064 54.7060 .8245 53 48.5345 59.0825 .8215 54 52.2231 63.8091 .8184 55 56.1921 68.9138 .8154 56 60.4626 74.4270 .8124 57 65.0578 80.3811 .8094 58 70.0022 86.8116 .8064 59 75.3224 93.7565 .8034 60 81.0469 101.2571 .8004 61 87.2064 109.3576 .7974 62 93.8341 118.1062 .7945 63 100.9655 127.5547 .7915 64 108.6389 137.7591 .7886 65 116.8954 148.7798 .7857 66 125.7795 160.6822 .7828 67 135.3387 173.5368 .7799 68 145.6245 187.4197 .7770 69 156.6919 202.4133 .7741 70 168.6005 218.6064 .7713 71 181.4142 236.0949 .7684 72 195.2016 254.9825 .7655 73 210.0370 275.3811 .7627 74 225.9998 297.4116 .7599 75 243.1758 321.2045 .7571 76 261.6571 346.9008 .7543 77 281.5431 374.6529 .7515 78 302.9403 404.6252 .7487 79 325.9638 436.9951 .7459 80 350.7370 471.9548 .7432 ------------------------------------------------------------ SUM 69.0904 ALPHA = 5.5390 REDUCTION(PRESENT VALUE) .0355 .0547 .0714 .0800 .0888 .0000 REDUCTION(TOTAL VALUE) .1966 .3033 .3953 .4430 .4916 .0000